The Spice Shanty
The Spice Shanty has a Trust Score of 75/100, which is a Grade of B+ and indicates a LOW risk level. The Spice Shanty claims their products are third-party tested, but does not specify which third-party does the testing. With a clean FDA record, The Spice Shanty appears to be a reasonably trustworthy brand.
The Spice Shanty Trust Summary
- Trust Score
- 75/100 (Good)
- Grade
- B+
- Risk Level
- LOW
- Third-Party Tested
- Yes (self-reported)
- FDA Recalls
- 0
- Adverse Events
- 0
The Spice Shanty has a trust score of 75/100 (Good). The brand is claims third-party testing (self-reported), has no FDA recalls on record and no adverse event reports.
Where to Buy The Spice Shanty
Purchase from trusted retailers. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Red Flags
- ⚠No GMP certification visible
Verified Strengths
- ✓Claims third-party testing
- ✓Clean FDA record — no warnings, recalls, or significant adverse events
Certifications
Third-party testing means an independent laboratory has verified this product's contents, purity, and potency match what's on the label.
FDA Record
Clean record — no FDA warnings, recalls, or significant adverse events.
Is The Spice Shanty Third-Party Tested?
Yes — The Spice Shanty is Third-party tested. This means an independent laboratory has verified that the products' contents, purity, and potency match their label claims.
Is The Spice Shanty a Good Brand?
The Spice Shanty scores 75/100 (B+) — this is an average score. There may be room for improvement in testing transparency or certifications. The Spice Shanty has a clean FDA record with no warnings or recalls. The brand holds third-party certifications (Third-party tested), which is a strong quality indicator.
About The Spice Shanty
The Spice Shanty is a US-based vitamin brand operating independently. The founding date of The Spice Shanty is unknown. They offer a range of supplements in the competitive online marketplace.
Product Specialization
The Spice Shanty focuses on vitamins. Their product line includes various formulations.
Testing & Certifications Explained
The Spice Shanty claims their products are third-party tested, but does not provide details about which third-party does the testing. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for consumers to verify the quality and safety of The Spice Shanty's products. Without knowing the specific testing protocols, it's impossible to assess the reliability of these claims. Consumers should seek brands that provide clear and verifiable evidence of third-party testing.
How The Spice Shanty Compares
Compared to competitors like Nature Made (Trust Score: 92/100, USP Verified) and NOW Foods (Trust Score: 88/100, many certifications), The Spice Shanty's Trust Score of 75/100 is lower. These competitors have established trust through recognized third-party certifications. Garden of Life (Trust Score: 70/100, multiple certifications) has a similar score but provides more transparency around certifications.
Buying Guidance
Given The Spice Shanty's B+ grade and lack of verifiable third-party testing, consumers should exercise caution. Purchase The Spice Shanty products directly from the company website or authorized retailers to ensure authenticity. Always check the product label for lot numbers and expiration dates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has The Spice Shanty had any recalls?
Are The Spice Shanty supplements third-party tested?
Is The Spice Shanty safe?
Is The Spice Shanty a good brand?
Get FDA Recall Alerts
We'll notify you when FDA recalls affect supplement brands you care about.
Compare Similar Brands
Brands in similar categories with comparable trust profiles. Compare certifications, scores, and safety records.
Nordic Naturals ProOmega
Grade A+ • Higher score
Renew Life Digestive Enzymes
Grade A+ • Higher score
Sports Research Collagen
Grade A+ • Higher score
Qunol
Grade A+ • Higher score
Absolute Collagen
Grade A+ • Higher score
Want more comparisons? Browse our supplement categories or check our buying guides.
How We Calculated This Score
Every brand starts with a baseline score of 70/100.
Points added for: Third-party certifications (NSF +15, USP +15, Informed Sport +10), publishing lab results (+10), clean regulatory record (+10), 10+ years in business (+10), organic certification (+5).
Points deducted for: FDA warning letters (-25), product recalls (-20), high adverse events (-15), no third-party testing (-15), proprietary blends (-10), no GMP (-10).
Score is capped at 0-100. Grade and risk level are derived from the final score.
All data sourced from FDA.gov, Health Canada (LNHPD / recalls-rappels), NSF.org, USP.org, and publicly available brand information. Last updated: 4/9/2026.
Promote Your Trust Score
Embed this badge on your site — it displays The Spice Shanty's verified trust score and links back to this profile page. Helps show buyers you're transparent about third-party testing.
<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/the-spice-shanty/" width="220" height="110" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="The Spice Shanty trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>
<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/the-spice-shanty/" width="320" height="160" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="The Spice Shanty trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>
<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/the-spice-shanty/" width="420" height="210" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="The Spice Shanty trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>
Paste the snippet anywhere on your site. The badge updates automatically when The Spice Shanty's trust score changes.
Own this brand? Contact us to update your information.
Want to find supplements you can trust?
Third-party testing is the single best indicator of supplement quality. We analyzed The Spice Shanty and 500+ other brands to find the ones that actually prove what's on the label.
See the best third-party tested supplements →Quick Facts
- Trust Score
- 75/100
- Grade
- B+
- Risk Level
- LOW
- Third-Party Tested
- Yes
- FDA Recalls
- 0
- Adverse Reports
- 0