Grade: B+

LOW RISK

Carnelian Naturals

Item: Carnelian Naturals
Rating: 75
Author: SupplementChecker

Carnelian Naturals has a SupplementChecker.co trust score of 75/100, earning a grade of B+ and a LOW risk level. Carnelian Naturals claims to offer third-party tested supplements, but does not specify which third-party performs the testing. This is a positive sign, but consumers should still exercise caution and verify claims.

Carnelian Naturals Trust Summary

Trust Score: 75/100 (Good)
Grade: B+
Risk Level: LOW
Third-Party Tested: Yes (self-reported)
FDA Recalls: 0
Adverse Events: 0

Carnelian Naturals has a trust score of 75/100 (Good). The brand is claims third-party testing (self-reported), has no FDA recalls on record and no adverse event reports.

Where to Buy Carnelian Naturals

Purchase from trusted retailers. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Buy on iHerb Buy on Amazon

Check another brand:

e.g. Nature Made, Thorne, NOW Foods...

Check

Red Flags

⚠No GMP certification visible

Verified Strengths

✓Claims third-party testing
✓Clean FDA record — no warnings, recalls, or significant adverse events

Certifications

Third-Party Tested

Third-party testing means an independent laboratory has verified this product's contents, purity, and potency match what's on the label.

FDA Record

FDA Warning Letters

Recalls

Adverse Reports

Clean record — no FDA warnings, recalls, or significant adverse events.

Is Carnelian Naturals Third-Party Tested?

Yes — Carnelian Naturals is Third-party tested. This means an independent laboratory has verified that the products' contents, purity, and potency match their label claims.

Is Carnelian Naturals a Good Brand?

Carnelian Naturals scores 75/100 (B+) — this is an average score. There may be room for improvement in testing transparency or certifications. Carnelian Naturals has a clean FDA record with no warnings or recalls. The brand holds third-party certifications (Third-party tested), which is a strong quality indicator.

About Carnelian Naturals

Carnelian Naturals is an independent supplement brand operating in the US. The founding date of Carnelian Naturals is unknown. They offer a range of supplements in various categories.

Product Specialization

Carnelian Naturals focuses on protein and vitamins. They offer a variety of products within these categories, catering to general health and wellness needs.

Testing & Certifications Explained

Carnelian Naturals claims their products are third-party tested, but they do not specify which third-party organization performs these tests. While the claim of third-party testing is a positive sign, the lack of transparency regarding the testing body means consumers must independently verify this claim. Without a named third-party, it's difficult to assess the rigor and reliability of the testing process. Consumers should look for specific certifications from reputable organizations when evaluating the quality and safety of supplements.

How Carnelian Naturals Compares

Compared to competitors like Transparent Labs (trust score 92/100) and Klean Athlete (trust score 88/100), Carnelian Naturals' trust score of 75/100 is lower. Both Transparent Labs and Klean Athlete have established third-party certifications, providing greater assurance of product quality and safety. Garden of Life (trust score 68/100) has a lower trust score and also lacks clear third-party certifications.

Buying Guidance

Before purchasing Carnelian Naturals products, consumers should attempt to verify the third-party testing claims. Look for specific certifications or lab results. Purchase from reputable retailers to ensure product authenticity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has Carnelian Naturals had any recalls?

No — as of 2026, Carnelian Naturals has zero FDA product recalls on record. They maintain a clean FDA record with no warning letters or significant adverse event reports. Carnelian Naturals received a trust score of 75/100 from SupplementChecker.

Are Carnelian Naturals supplements third-party tested?

Yes — Carnelian Naturals supplements are third-party tested. They hold the following certifications: third-party tested (self-reported). Third-party testing means an independent lab has verified the product's contents, purity, and potency match the label claims.

Is Carnelian Naturals safe?

Carnelian Naturals received a trust score of 75/100 (grade: B+, risk level: LOW). This score is calculated from FDA records, third-party certifications, adverse event reports, and transparency practices. No FDA warnings or recalls are on record.

Grade A+ • Higher score

Want more comparisons? Browse our supplement categories or check our buying guides.

How We Calculated This Score

Every brand starts with a baseline score of 70/100.

Points added for: Third-party certifications (NSF +15, USP +15, Informed Sport +10), publishing lab results (+10), clean regulatory record (+10), 10+ years in business (+10), organic certification (+5).

Points deducted for: FDA warning letters (-25), product recalls (-20), high adverse events (-15), no third-party testing (-15), proprietary blends (-10), no GMP (-10).

Score is capped at 0-100. Grade and risk level are derived from the final score.

All data sourced from FDA.gov, Health Canada (LNHPD / recalls-rappels), NSF.org, USP.org, and publicly available brand information. Last updated: 4/9/2026.

Promote Your Trust Score

Embed this badge on your site — it displays Carnelian Naturals's verified trust score and links back to this profile page. Helps show buyers you're transparent about third-party testing.

Small · 220×110

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/carnelian-naturals/" width="220" height="110" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Carnelian Naturals trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Medium · 320×160

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/carnelian-naturals/" width="320" height="160" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Carnelian Naturals trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Large · 420×210

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/carnelian-naturals/" width="420" height="210" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Carnelian Naturals trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Paste the snippet anywhere on your site. The badge updates automatically when Carnelian Naturals's trust score changes.

Own this brand? Contact us to update your information.

Want to find supplements you can trust?

Third-party testing is the single best indicator of supplement quality. We analyzed Carnelian Naturals and 500+ other brands to find the ones that actually prove what's on the label.

See the best third-party tested supplements →

Quick Facts

Trust Score: 75/100
Grade: B+
Risk Level: LOW
Third-Party Tested: Yes
FDA Recalls: 0
Adverse Reports: 0

⚠ No GMP certification visible